Contractor vs umbrella vs paye comes down to employment costs. At £500 a day over 48 weeks, agency PAYE pays £76,157.40 a year, a limited company outside IR35 pays £74,654.38, and an umbrella pays £69,889.86 with no pension taken. The gaps come from employer National Insurance, the umbrella margin and dividend tax, not from your income tax band.
How do the three routes work?
With agency PAYE, the agency or the client employs you directly and runs your payroll. Income tax and employee National Insurance come out of your gross pay, and the agency pays employer National Insurance as its own cost, so it never reduces what you see. You get paid holidays, sick pay and a workplace pension, and your take home is simple to read on a payslip.
With an umbrella company, the umbrella employs you and invoices the client for your assignment rate. Employer National Insurance, the apprenticeship levy, the employer pension and the weekly margin all come out of that rate before your gross pay is worked out, and only then do income tax and employee National Insurance come off. GOV.UK explains that the umbrella is your employer and pays your wages through PAYE, while the agency finds the work.
With a limited company, your own company invoices the client and you pay yourself a mix of salary and dividends. The company pays corporation tax on its profit, and you pay dividend tax on the dividends you take, which is why this route needs more admin and an accountant. That is the first thing to grasp in any contractor vs umbrella vs paye comparison: the same day rate does not give you the same gross pay on every route.
How much do you take home on each route?
The table below settles the contractor vs umbrella vs paye question at £500 a day, working 5 days a week for 48 weeks, which is a contract value of £120,000 a year in England, with no student loan and no other income. The limited company route uses a salary of £12,570, and the umbrella route uses a margin of £25 a week. Run your own day rate through our contractor calculator to see your own figures.
| Route | Take home a year | Take home a month |
|---|---|---|
| Agency PAYE | £76,157.40 | £6,346.45 |
| Limited company outside IR35 | £74,654.38 | £6,221.20 |
| Umbrella, pension opted out | £69,889.86 | £5,824.16 |
| Umbrella, pension enrolled | £68,574.68 | £5,714.56 |
Agency PAYE pays the most cash at this rate, £1,503.02 a year ahead of the limited company and £6,267.54 ahead of the umbrella with no pension. That surprises people who expect the limited company to win, but at the same gross amount PAYE has no corporation tax and no dividend tax to pay, and no employer costs are taken from your pay. A £90,000 salary after tax keeps £62,757 a year, which shows the same PAYE maths at a lower income.
Why does an umbrella pay less than PAYE?
The umbrella gap is employment costs, not income tax. The umbrella must pay employer National Insurance at 15% on your earnings above £5,000 a year, and that alone takes thousands from a £120,000 assignment rate before your gross pay is set.
The apprenticeship levy adds 0.5%, the employer pension adds 3% of qualifying earnings, and the margin takes £15 to £30 a week. GOV.UK confirms the umbrella deducts its operating costs, employer National Insurance, the employer pension contribution, holiday pay and the apprenticeship levy before working out your gross pay.
This is why a contractor vs umbrella vs paye comparison has to start with the uplifted rate, not the headline day rate. At £500 a day, the umbrella rate must rise to £584.88 a day with the pension enrolled, or £579.38 a day with it opted out, to leave the same £120,000 of gross pay. Always compare the uplifted umbrella rate with the PAYE rate, or the comparison will mislead you.
When does a limited company pay more?
A limited company beats the umbrella when the contract is outside IR35, because dividends are not hit by National Insurance and corporation tax is 19% on profits up to £50,000. At £120,000 the company pays corporation tax of £24,418.04 and dividend tax of £19,792.08, yet still keeps £74,654.38, which is £4,764.52 more than the umbrella with no pension. The advantage grows as the day rate rises, because more income moves through the dividend route instead of PAYE.
So the contractor vs umbrella vs paye ranking at a fixed day rate is simple: PAYE pays most, the limited company sits in the middle, and the umbrella pays least. The limited company does not beat agency PAYE at the same gross amount, because the company pays corporation tax and then you pay dividend tax on what is left, while PAYE only pays income tax and employee National Insurance. Dividend tax is 10.75% at the basic rate and 35.75% at the higher rate after the £500 allowance in 2026/27, so the double hit bites once your income passes £50,270.
What does IR35 change?
IR35 is the one factor that can overturn a contractor vs umbrella vs paye ranking overnight, because an inside decision removes the dividend advantage entirely. If the client decides the contract is inside IR35, the fee payer deducts the same tax and National Insurance as an employer, so take home matches agency PAYE at £76,157.40 on our £500 a day example. If the client is small, your own company works out a deemed employment payment instead, which leaves £68,431.32 in cash plus £6,000 held in the company at £120,000.
Since April 2021, medium and large private sector clients decide your status and give you a Status Determination Statement, and the rules are judged contract by contract. From 6 April 2026, higher size thresholds mean more clients count as small, so for those clients the decision passes back to your own company. GOV.UK explains the off payroll working rules and when they apply.
Which route should you choose?
Choose the umbrella when the contract is inside IR35, when the engagement is short, or when you want employment rights and no company admin. The cost is real, about £6,267.54 a year against PAYE at £500 a day, so weigh it against the sick pay, holiday pay and simplicity you get in return.
Your own answer to the contractor vs umbrella vs paye choice depends on your day rate, your IR35 status and how much you value the safety net that comes with being employed. Choose the limited company when the contract is outside IR35 and your day rate is £350 or more, because the gap over the umbrella is then worth the accountancy fees and the admin. Choose agency PAYE when it is offered at the same day rate, because it pays the most cash and carries the fewest costs.
How do you compare your own figures?
- Work out your contract value from your day rate, days a week and weeks a year, and write it down before you compare anything.
- Run those figures through our contractor calculator and read all three routes side by side, then check the same salary on our free salary calculator to see the PAYE maths.
- Ask the client for the Status Determination Statement in writing, so you know whether IR35 puts the limited company route on the table at all.
- Ask the umbrella for a written breakdown showing your gross pay, the margin, the pension and the holiday pay, and check the gross pay against the assignment rate.
- Compare two salaries side by side on our salary comparison tool if you are weighing a permanent offer against contracting, and count the pension, holiday and sick pay in the total.
Do the sums before you sign, because in a contractor vs umbrella vs paye decision the cheapest headline rate is rarely the best deal once employer costs, dividend tax and IR35 are counted.
Common questions
Which pays the most: umbrella, limited company or PAYE?
At £500 a day over 48 weeks, agency PAYE pays the most cash at £76,157.40 a year. A limited company outside IR35 pays £74,654.38, and an umbrella pays £69,889.86 with no pension or £68,574.68 with the pension enrolled.
What day rate do I need through an umbrella to match £500 a day on PAYE?
About £584.88 a day with the pension enrolled, or £579.38 a day with it opted out. The umbrella rate has to cover employer National Insurance, the apprenticeship levy, the employer pension and the margin before your gross pay is reached.
Is an umbrella company worth it?
It gives you continuous employment, statutory sick pay and holiday pay, and no company admin. At £500 a day it costs about £6,267.54 a year in take home against PAYE, so it is worth it when you value the simplicity and the employment rights more than the cash.
Does IR35 decide the route for me?
Inside IR35 with a medium or large client, the fee payer deducts tax and National Insurance like an employer, so the limited company advantage mostly disappears. Outside IR35 you are free to choose, and the limited company usually pays more than the umbrella.