Contractor Calculator
A contractor calculator compares take home pay for the same day rate under agency PAYE, an umbrella company and a limited company. At £500 a day for 48 weeks, agency PAYE pays £76,157.40 a year, a limited company outside IR35 pays £74,654.38 and an umbrella pays £68,574.68 with pension enrolled. Enter your day rate below to compare all three routes.
Compare your contractor routes
Enter your figures below, then click Calculate. All three routes use the same day rate, days and weeks, so the comparison is like for like.
Off by default. A single director company cannot claim it.
Contract value: £120,000.00 a year. Pension enrolment applies to the umbrella route only. Student loan is deducted through PAYE on the agency and umbrella routes only.
The three contractor routes explained
Agency PAYE
With agency PAYE, the agency pays you as an employee for the assignment. Tax and employee National Insurance come from your gross pay, and the agency pays employer National Insurance as its own cost. It does not reduce your pay. Your student loan, where it applies, is handled through PAYE. This route is simple, and at the figures in the worked examples it pays the most cash.
Umbrella company
An umbrella company employs you and invoices the client or agency for the assignment value. Employer National Insurance, the apprenticeship levy, the employer pension and the weekly margin are taken from that assignment value before your gross pay is worked out. Holiday pay is 12.07% of your gross pay and it is part of gross pay, never an extra amount on top. Your employee pension, tax, employee National Insurance and student loan then come from gross pay.
Limited company
With a limited company outside IR35, your company receives the contract value, pays your salary and employer National Insurance, and pays corporation tax on the profit that remains. The profit after corporation tax can be paid to you as dividends, and dividend tax applies to those dividends. Your IR35 status decides which version of this route applies, and it is judged contract by contract.
If you are inside IR35 and your client is medium or large, the fee payer deducts the same tax and National Insurance as an employer, so your take home is the same as agency PAYE. If your client is small, your company calculates a deemed employment payment instead. That payment is the fees less the 5% allowance, less salary already paid and employer National Insurance on it, then grossed down by 100 divided by 115 for employer National Insurance on the deemed payment.
Worked examples at £500 a day
These examples use a day rate of £500, 5 days a week, 48 weeks a year, a contract value of £120,000, England, no student loan and no other income.
| Route | Take home per year | Take home per month | Key figures |
|---|---|---|---|
| Agency PAYE | £76,157.40 | £6,346.45 | Tax £39,432.00; National Insurance £4,410.60 |
| Umbrella, pension enrolled | £68,574.68 | £5,714.56 | Gross pay £102,362.86; tax £27,528.82; National Insurance £4,057.86; employee pension £2,201.50; pension pot £3,522.40 |
| Umbrella, opted out | £69,889.86 | £5,824.16 | Gross pay £103,506.49; tax £29,535.90; National Insurance £4,080.73 |
| Limited company outside IR35, salary £12,570 | £74,654.38 | £6,221.20 | Corporation tax £24,418.04; dividend tax £19,792.08 |
| Limited company outside IR35, salary £5,000 | £73,901.71 | £6,158.48 | Corporation tax £26,725.00; dividend tax £19,373.29 |
| Inside IR35, fee payer | £76,157.40 | £6,346.45 | Same tax and National Insurance as agency PAYE |
| Inside IR35, small client | £68,431.32 cash | £5,702.61 cash | Plus £6,000 retained in the company |
The umbrella uplift explained
The umbrella rate has to cover costs that PAYE does not charge to you directly. At £500 a day, the assignment value must rise to £140,370.90 a year to leave gross pay of £120,000 after employer National Insurance of £17,250.00, the apprenticeship levy of £600.00, the employer pension of £1,320.90 and margin of £1,200.00. That is £584.88 a day. Opted out, the figure is £579.38 a day, because there is no employer pension to fund.
Use the uplift in the results above when you compare rates. A £500 a day umbrella rate is not the same as a £500 a day PAYE rate, and the calculator shows the gap in cash terms.
Traps to avoid
- Compare the same day rate on every route. A higher umbrella rate can look better until employer costs and margin are taken out.
- Holiday pay is part of gross pay. If an umbrella quotes holiday pay on top of the assignment rate, ask for the figures in writing and check the gross pay that results.
- Opting out of the pension raises cash take home by £1,315.18 at £500 a day, but it costs £2,007.08 in extra tax and it loses the £3,522.40 pension pot. The pot includes £1,320.90 from the employer.
- A company with only one director, who is also the only employee paid above £5,000 a year, cannot claim the Employment Allowance. GOV.UK states this rule, and this calculator leaves the allowance off by default.
- IR35 is judged for each contract. A change of client, or a change in how you work, can change the result, so check the status for every new contract.
- Student loan repayments come through PAYE on the agency and umbrella routes only. They never come from limited company dividends. On the inside IR35 fee payer route they are paid through Self Assessment, so they do not reduce the PAYE figures shown here.
- The apprenticeship levy is shown as 0.5% of gross pay. That is the standard disclosed simplification used in this calculator.
- Dividend tax uses the £500 allowance inside the basic rate band. That leaves £37,200 of taxable income after the allowance at 10.75% when the salary uses the full personal allowance.
Method and sources
This calculator uses 2026/27 rates. The personal allowance is £12,570, and it falls by £1 for every £2 of adjusted net income over £100,000. Income tax in England is 20% to £50,270, 40% to £125,140 and 45% above, applied on the basic rate band of £37,700 of taxable income. Scotland uses its own bands, from 19% to 48%. Employee National Insurance is 8% from £12,570 to £50,270 and 2% above. Employer National Insurance is 15% above £5,000 a year. Pension auto enrolment is 8% of qualifying earnings from £6,240 to £50,270, with 3% from the employer and 5% from the employee. Corporation tax is 19% on profits up to £50,000, 25% above £250,000, with marginal relief between those profits. Dividend tax is 10.75% at the basic rate, 35.75% at the higher rate and 39.35% at the additional rate, after a £500 allowance. Student loan thresholds are Plan 1 £26,900, Plan 2 £29,385, Plan 4 £33,795, Plan 5 £25,000 at 9%, and Postgraduate £21,000 at 6%.
Results are estimates only and they are not financial advice. Your payslip or company accounts may differ if your circumstances change. To see how a pension payment changes monthly take home pay, use the pension calculator. To work out take home pay from a yearly salary, use the free salary calculator.
Sources
Inside IR35: the number that decides whether the contract pays
This page already explains the three contractor routes, and it already mentions inside IR35. What it does not do is put a number on inside IR35, and that number is the one that decides whether a contract is worth taking. Inside IR35 means the client or agency treats you as an employee for tax. Tax and National Insurance come out before the money reaches you, and there is no room for expenses or dividends to change the result.
Take the worked example this page already uses, £500 a day. Five days a week for 46 weeks is 230 days and £115,000 a year. Inside IR35, with a standard 1257L code, no pension and no student loan, the figures are: income tax £36,432, employee National Insurance £4,310.60, take home pay £74,257.40 a year, £6,188.12 a month, £322.86 a day across the 230 working days. That is the floor. If you are offered the same £500 a day outside IR35 through a limited company, the take home figure depends on your salary and dividend split and on corporation tax, and this page does not publish a single figure for it, because there is no single figure. Run the inside number first. If the contract is inside IR35 and £322.86 a day after tax does not beat what you would take home as a permanent employee, plus something for the holiday, sick pay and pension you lose, the rate is too low.
A shorter version of the same table, for the day rates people actually get offered:
| Day rate, inside IR35 | Gross a year, 230 days | Take home a year | Take home a day |
|---|---|---|---|
| £400 | £92,000 | £63,917.40 | £277.90 |
| £500 | £115,000 | £74,257.40 | £322.86 |
| £600 | £138,000 | £84,926.40 | £369.25 |
Two things to watch on top of the table. First, umbrella companies take a margin and an employment cost, and the margin comes out of the day rate before tax, so the gross in the table is what the umbrella receives, not what you receive. Ask the umbrella for the assignment rate and the margin in writing. Second, inside IR35 work still counts for your state pension and for employment rights in a limited way, but it does not give you the same holiday or sick pay as a permanent job. Price that in, or you will compare a contractor day rate with a permanent salary and think the contract pays more than it does.
Sources checked 14 November 2026: HMRC, off payroll working, IR35, inside and outside IR35. Take home figures are our own hand calculations on 2026/27 tax and National Insurance rates for England, standard 1257L code, no pension, no student loan, 230 working days a year.
Frequently asked questions
Which pays the most: umbrella, limited company or agency PAYE?
On £500 a day over 48 weeks, agency PAYE pays the most cash at £76,157.40 a year, then a limited company outside IR35 at £74,654.38, then an umbrella at £68,574.68 with pension or £69,889.86 opted out. The umbrella gap is employment costs and margin, not income tax.
What day rate do I need through an umbrella to match £500 a day on PAYE?
About £584.88 a day with pension enrolled, or £579.38 a day opted out. The umbrella rate has to cover employer National Insurance, the apprenticeship levy, the employer pension and the margin before your gross pay is reached.
Is an umbrella company worth it?
An umbrella gives you continuous employment, statutory sick pay and holiday pay, and no company admin, but it costs roughly £7,582.72 a year in take-home compared with agency PAYE at £500 a day, and about £6,079.70 compared with a limited company outside IR35. Whether that is worth it depends on how much you value the simplicity and employment rights.
What is the umbrella margin and how much should it be?
The margin is the umbrella’s weekly fee, usually £15 to £30 a week, and it comes off the assignment rate before your gross pay is worked out. If an umbrella charges much more than £30 a week, ask what extra service you are getting for it.
How does IR35 change my take-home pay?
If you are inside IR35 and your client is medium or large, the fee payer deducts the same tax and National Insurance as an employer, so your take-home is the same as agency PAYE. If your client is small, your company calculates a deemed employment payment instead, which gives £68,431.32 cash plus £6,000 retained in the company at £120,000. If you are outside IR35, the limited company route pays £74,654.38.
Can my limited company claim the Employment Allowance?
Not if you are the only director and the only employee paid above £5,000 a year. GOV.UK states that a single-director company cannot claim it. If there is a second director or employee paid above £5,000, the company can claim up to £10,500 off its employer National Insurance bill.